Wednesday, 24 October 2012

Feminism is not a dirty word.


I wrote this to submit to our college newsletter; it will probably need to be edited and shortened  but I wanted to keep my first stab at it here. 

I have a friend from home who went to another university, and managed in her three years to fall into a particularly defined role. She was an activist for many causes like Amnesty International, took action against cuts for student funding and the NHS, occupied her university, has been on more marches than I can count, but perhaps most vocally of all, she’s a feminist. A very loud feminist. She hosts events, writes for her feminist society’s blog, and has made herself such an enemy in a man who has particularly different views to her on feminist issues that she was sponsored  hundreds of pounds to go on a date with him. That’s quite a reputation to get.

So when she asked me about the feminist scene in Oxford, I didn’t really know what to say. I shared a vague view that women and men should be treated equally in society, have equal opportunities, equal pay for equal work, and so on. I also agreed that it probably isn’t the case yet. But, I thought, there’s not a lot I can do about that, I don’t see any immediate problems I can fix, and I’ll probably be more useful to the world if I just concentrate on getting my degree. That meant, in my mind, I definitely wasn’t a feminist, thank goodness – because really, who would want to be associated with an outdated stereotype of bra-burning, armpit hair and body odour?

Over the last couple of terms, a couple of things have woken me up to the need for our generation of students and young adults to stake our claim on feminism – not the stereotyped version, but the heart of it, to say that the society we are part of and will increasingly shape should be one in which everyone is valued equally. The first thing that woke me up to this was a Facebook group, started last year, called “Misogyny Overheard at Oxford”. On it, I found numerous examples of stories of women being patronised, mocked, groped, and harassed, sometimes in the name of banter from their peers, and often as a result of institutionalised sexism which is rife in an institution as old as ours. From this, and similar communities on Facebook I came across the website “Everyday Sexism”, which recounts thousands of examples of women’s experiences in families, in workplaces and on the streets. The problems of sexism are literally everywhere when you start looking for them. I began reading more, from Caitlin Moran’s “How to be a Woman” to articles, news stories and blogs.  I’ve learned about the huge problems of victim blaming, where as a society we excuse rapists because women were “asking for it” by the way they dress or act. Depressing as some of the statistics and stories are, what I’ve read is encouraging – there ARE people, normal people, working to do something about this kind of inequality. No, they can’t fix everything single handedly, but they’re taking the time to do something, and to gather people onside.

Let me add a couple of qualifiers here – firstly, this is nothing to do with “women against men.” Like with any umbrella term, the name of feminism has been used by those with an anti-men agenda to push. That’s not okay. But it doesn’t mean that everyone who wants equality is anti-men, and it certainly doesn’t mean that men don’t have a very important part to play in bringing it about.  Secondly, this is not meant to downplay the hurtful experiences of other groups who are subject to discrimination and prejudice. It’s not to say that men are not subject to gender discrimination either. It’s not to say that homophobia, transphobia and racism are not serious and important issues. Trying to solve one problem doesn't mean we should ignore the rest, and most people would recognise that any attempts to bring about a more equal society are going to beneficial for all marginalised groups.

So qualifiers aside, what about us at Worcester? I've tried floating the word “feminism” about with friends and the odd drunk person at parties, to see the reactions I get. A couple of people have just walked off, in jest or otherwise. While my friends might have been making a joke about feminism being boring, the attitude is a real one: we don’t need that. It’s irrelevant, boring, and most importantly might challenge some parts of “lad-culture”. We couldn't have that. Some have seemed a little fearful of the word, as if not confident enough to claim it themselves: “ I'm definitely not a feminist but...” followed by some brilliant statement about the need to bridge the pay gap, for instance. Others have looked tentatively excited and surprised to find someone else using this word, sharing these concerns, trying to get people to listen. Could it be that there are in fact a whole load of us, hidden feminists at Worcester, both men and women who agree that actually, we’d like to be part of a society in which people are treated equally, and that that includes women?  If that’s the case, let’s come out of the woodwork and start talking. Start sharing those instances of every day sexism wherever we find them, so they can’t be ignored as a one off. Start calling people out on rape-jokes and find something funnier to say instead. Let’s share ideas, stories and ambitions, let’s start doing those little things that add up to bigger change. If you’re interested at all, if you might want to get involved, or just to listen in on a few ideas, drop me an email.

“Feminism is the radical notion that women are people.” There’s nothing to be scared of in that.

Tuesday, 23 October 2012

Nameless night time poem.

There's a stirring that I don't understand,
When compassion is the last thing I feel.
A deep longing to take part in your plan.
A heavy weight that pushes me to kneel... 

Move me to pray for a world that is hurting,
Torn and divided but still we're flirting
With power and fame,
Seduced without shame,
By empty promises that house
But a dying flame. 
For our cult of the self,
Our addiction to wealth,
We're sorry and we turn to cry
We need your help. 
Move us to repent,
For even as the ones you've sent,
We're tempted by a gospel 
That was never what you meant. 
Take the shackles off our feet,
Release our tongues to pray,
To intercede for a broken world
And with our lives now to obey.
Fill us, send us, guide us, use us.
Bring your kingdom near us.
Build your kingdom now on earth,
Your will be done, God, hear us. 

Sunday, 21 October 2012

Uncertain that... I'm a Proper Feminist.

My mother once told me that she couldn't understand how she'd raised a daughter who didn't call herself a feminist. At the time, I was convinced that feminism was this bunch of angry women who just couldn't accept that men and women are different. They'd be much more content, I thought, if they could accept that God had given us different roles to men, mainly submission in marriage and shutting up in church. Once they accepted that, they'd realise that it wasn't an oppressive, demeaning view of women, but in fact affirming and liberating. My main evidence for all this was a book I read about a woman's heart, the message of which was essentially "As women we want to be told we're beautiful. Men don't always tell us this properly, so we should look to God for it instead." Quite how that message affirmed that we should submit in marriage and shut up in church I'm not sure, but I was so taken by the fact that this book seemed to understand me perfectly, that I believed everything it told me about my station in life too.

Fortunately, I've since moved on. I studied theology better, talked to some wise people, met a few great women, tried a bit of preaching myself, and concluded that maybe God doesn't want women to sit down and shut up at all. With that sorted, my eyes were opened to the huge and very current problems of gender inequality, and I started to see what those feminists had been talking about all along. One read of How to be a Woman later, and I was converted.

Now, there are a good few reasons why I might not be a Proper Feminist. For a start, I've never taken any active protest, beyond talking. I've signed up to all the Facebook groups that make me feel part of the feminist community in Oxford, but I've only contributed a couple of times, and never actually got involved with anything. I've started to challenge casual sexism wherever I see it among my friends, but sometimes I choose to avoid the eye-rolling, or "banter!" retort, and don't. I'm a little scared of calling myself a feminist because the Proper Feminists, who actually do stuff about it and would never let casual sexism slide and go on marches and are far more clear on their opinions about everything than I am, might notice and expose me as a slightly uncertain fraud.

But here's the big reason why I'm not sure that I'm a Proper Feminist.

Feminists have to be Pro-Choice, and they have to campaign for abortion rights.

Now, this is where I get uncertain. On the one hand, I'm clear enough about what I think about abortion, clear enough for myself at least. I am, I think, clear in my own mind that I don't think it's right, in most circumstances, although put me in one of the nightmare situations that people always ask you about ("what if you were raped? What if you were likely to die in giving birth?") and I honestly don't know what I'd do. But in principle, yes, I think it's wrong.

On the other hand, I'm still working out what I think about Christian ethics and their relationship with social policy. There's this bit that really gets me in 1 Corinthians 5 about associating with sexually immoral people. Paul says, if someone calls themselves a Christian and yet is living a sexually immoral lifestyle, don't associate with them. But - and this is the bit he feels important enough to add - he's not talking about people who are not Christians. There is a different standard for people who call themselves followers of Jesus. I think there's an important reason for this, in that as a Christian, I want to live according to certain ethics because I personally know the God who gives us those ethical codes. I want to live in the way that he wants me to, because I know him and I love him and I want to please him and I want to represent him to the rest of the world. When we tell someone the gospel, we invite them into relationship with God first and foremost. The change in lifestyle and a new system of ethics is just the result of that. So, I don't think that it is the place of Christians to be preaching to the world on their morals. That's not what we're commanded to do - it is only once we've made disciples that we're to teach them to obey Jesus, not to teach people to obey before they know or love him. The fact that I think abortion is wrong means that I could not do it in good conscience as a follower of Jesus. But who am I to preach to others on their moral positions, when really I should be introducing them to God, the author of Good.

In theory then, I don't think we should be attempting to hold the world, who don't know Jesus, to the ethical standards that Jesus calls his followers to. In that sense, I'm Pro-Choice. I fully accept that those who don't have a moral problem with abortion, and feel it necessary in their circumstances, should have the right to do so legally, without fear, and without resorting to desperate and dangerous methods.

But on the other hand (is this the third hand now?) - there must be a responsibility to fight injustice and to act of the oppressed, because that's what God tells us he's doing. His business in the world is fighting for the widow, the orphan, the poor, the voiceless. He calls us to advocacy on their behalf. So while there's no place for Christians to preach at others about their moral choices which are irrelevant for people who don't claim to follow Jesus, perhaps there is a place for trying to intervene where there is some oppression and injustice towards the helpless. Abortion seems to be the issue where these two things cross over at the most sensitive and difficult point, and as such, I just don't know what I think.

So I can't support the Pro-Choice campaigns that litter feminist Facebook groups, I can't go and join rallies on the street, and I can't protest against the 40 days for life vigils that have been happening around the country. I do feel the acute sense of the responsibility God gives us to fight for the weak and the oppressed.
But on the other hand, I can't support the Pro-Choice lot, who don't seem to understand how little sense it makes to try to inflict Christian moral values onto a world who doesn't know God. In doing so, they only seem to want to force people backwards into a dangerous world of illegal abortions and fear, shame and secrecy, which is not safe for anyone.

I'm uncertain that I'm a Proper Feminist. But I'd like to be, if they'd take me with my uncertainty.

Friday, 19 October 2012

Motto

"O Lord help us to be masters of ourselves that we may be the servants of others."

- Sir  Alexander Henry Paterson

I'm writing a book...

Writing a book has always been one of the top things on my bucket list (you know, the list of things you want to do before you die). But I always thought life would just present me with the right time to do it, probably at some point after I become Wise.
As I've thought more about what I want to do next year when I graduate* and have to go in to the World of Work, I just don't feel ready. I know it makes me sound like a knob, because most people don't have the luxury of just not 'feeling ready' to work, and I'm not sure I do either really. But my thinking is something like this: I've changed a lot at university, so most people who know me would say. I've grown up, I've had therapy, I've had some convictions shaken up, and others I've just better thought through. I've questioned my identity, I've discovered new identities. I've been left knowing far more about theology than I did before, and far less about myself and about life. That takes some processing, and I think it's a worthwhile process. When I'm in Oxford, I don't have much time to think and to process, there are a lot of essays and a lot of people. When I do find myself thinking, it usually means I forfeit sleep, or a decent essay. So if I want to think, to process, to work out if I've got anything to say to the world and how to go about saying it, I'll need a bit of time and space. 

I know the first thing I want to write though, my book. I can't explain what it is though, because I'm scared that if I try, it'll sound crap and I won't want to write it any more. It's a very fragile idea at the moment. But I want to try, to plan it, research it, write sample chapters, and see if anyone wants me to do it. If they don't, I'll probably just write it anyway, and consider myself one of those genius types who is only appreciated after their time. 

Today, I did Step One in the Grand Book Writing Plan. I bought a notebook for scribblings and thoughts. Actually, I did Step Two as well. I scribbled some thoughts. I'm not sure where one goes next in writing a book, but I know I need to get far enough into it that I can justify not diving straight into a graduate scheme or church apprenticeship straight after university, to make it a real project that is actually worth my time and energy. Maybe while I throw myself into that, I'll have time for all that other thinking I want to do too. We'll see. 

*I won't actually graduate for a while after I finish my degree because of Oxford's nonsensical system, but you know, I'll have finished the part of life where people tell me what to write and when. 

Questioning the Art of Questioning


[[This was originally a Facebook note, written in September 2012. I thought I’d post it here as a starting point, because it explains why I’m doing so much asking and not much answering at the moment.]]


My dad is a little odd, and so as well as postcards on our fridge and a sign that says ‘Mad House’ on the kitchen door, we also have a cartoon in our downstairs toilet – you can see it here:http://www.cartoonchurch.com/content/cc/i-have/ 
Being someone who would place themselves on the left hand side of this cartoon, both evangelical and vaguely charismatic, I’ve come to think it’s a shame that we tend to consider questioning a ‘liberal’ thing to do. (I also think there’s a place for crossing ourselves and such things in evangelical worship, but that’s another story.) The rest of us are missing out, perhaps through fear. 

A few years ago I heard a testimony from a young woman at my church who had lived in a Muslim country, and grown up in a Muslim tradition in which she felt there was no space for questions and for doubts. Not knowing nearly enough about Islam I couldn’t comment on how true this is of Islamic teaching as a whole, but at least in the experience of this young woman, to question God would be among the worst things she could do. She spoke of the freedom she found in discovering that the God of the Bible was big enough to take our questions, our doubts, our wonderings and our confusion. 

When I heard this, it rung true in my experience. I had some friends who were, in their own ways, interested in my faith. Some tentatively curious, others more opinionated and up for debate. The advice I was given by older Christians was to encourage them to question - that it’s good to be questioning who we are, why we’re here, and what the world is about. It’s even better to question who Jesus was, how we know, why he might have come and if we can trust him. It’s good to ask what relevance God could possibly have for my life and whether I want in. Evangelicals love questioning, when it’s done by people who don’t know Jesus, because we trust that in the midst of their searching and questioning, God will meet them with answers, with truth that will draw them to him. 

But what about those of us who are on the ‘other side’ of that process? Those of us who have asked who Jesus is, why he came and whether we can trust him, and who have concluded that all signs point to yes? What is our attitude to questions then? In my experience, we’re more inclined towards fear when Christians start to ask questions. Just think of the way we talk about those initial questions of those who are not Christians, questions like “Why so much suffering?” “Is God homophobic?” “What about when good people don’t believe the right thing?” We consider these ‘stumbling blocks’, barriers that need to be broken down before someone is willing to consider Jesus. We address these issues over lunchtime talks of our mission weeks before the focus on the important questions about Jesus in the evenings. 
I’m not saying there’s anything wrong with that at all, because these are real and important questions that need to be taken seriously alongside our conversations with people about Jesus Christ. But the implication is that these are questions for the not-yet-Christian, which the now-become-Christian won’t need to ask anymore. After all, they’ve been answered in a series of lunchtime talks. So when a follower of Jesus starts to ask questions like these, or keeps asking the questions even having heard the lunchtime talk answers, when a Christian goes through personal experiences that leave them struggling to accept the black and white answers they once had and needs to explore the grey, the evangelical instinct kicks in. It’s like there’s a little radar system in conservative churches, so we can home in on those who are wrestling with big questions, and sort out their confusion. With all the best intentions in the world, we want to sit them down and remind them of what they heard at that lunchtime talk a few years ago. To take them back to the clear cut, Biblical view that they used to find made perfect sense. While doing so might be helpful in some situations, and I know I have been really encouraged by friends who’ve wisely opened up the Bible with me and reminded me of the things that God says to us there, we also risk losing something very important and very Biblical – the art of questioning. 

As my friend giving her testimony found, the God we meet in the Bible is big enough to take our questions, our frustrations, our experiences and our confusion – and He even gives us models in the Bible of how to question! Start reading the Psalms, the prophets, stories of people God called throughout the history of his people, and you can’t escape the cries and the questions – “why the suffering, God? How long, God? What are you doing, God? Is this what you meant, God? Has something gone wrong, God? I don’t understand, God.” The remarkable thing is that these questioners are not turned away by God but loved by Him. They don’t always get the answers they want; sometimes the answer isn’t the important thing. But God uses the questions – sometimes the answers are so surprising that they force God’s people to press in closer and depend on him more (see Habakkuk 1:5 – “you won’t believe the answer even if I tell you. Look and be amazed.”) Sometimes the very process of questioning and crying out to God is what leads to a deeper understanding of all He’s been doing, and lead us to more confident prayer (try Psalm 13 or 74). The point is, God can take our questions, we only have to open the Bible to see that. 

So in our well intentioned encouragements, in our barrier-breaking talks, in our walk alongside friends who seem to have landed in a patch of grey - please let’s not seek to rid the journey of questions, let’s not leave all the puzzling to our more liberal brothers and sisters. If God is big enough to handle them, we’d hope our churches can be too. Perhaps we could pray that God will show us more of Himself even through our questions, as He did so many times for those who wondered long before us.